Too much ‘democracy’?

A bit of a grumpy-pumpkin post today.

I handed  out how-to-vote cards at the early voting centre down in Burgundy Street in Heidelberg on Tuesday.  The early voting centre opened last week, three weeks before the election on 7th September.

IMG_20130829_095646

Three weeks? you might ask.  Surely with postal voting, there’s no need to have early voting three weeks ahead of the election.  A week before, maybe- but three weeks? Two- or three-hour shifts for party members handing out how-to-vote literature between 8.30 and 5.00, five days a week for three weeks.  That’s a lot of volunteers- quite apart from the ones you need for letter-boxing and manning the booth on the day.  Surely it could be postal voting until a week before the election?

It would have been a bit bleak in the cold winds of last week (20th-24th August) but I must admit that it was quite pleasant last Tuesday when I was there.  I’ve never experienced any animosity between people handing out how-to-vote cards representing different parties at polling booths and Tuesday was no exception.  On the contrary: it seems that, this election particularly, no body is particularly happy with the choices on offer.

IMG_20130829_095950

I was surprised by how many people came to vote.  I don’t think that five minutes went by without someone coming in.  These days parties are holding their launches as little as a week before the election, withholding their figures until the last days of the campaign, and drip-feeding their policies in yet another confected photo-opportunity over a four-week period.  Yet, you can vote three weeks ahead if you want to.

This voting booth is located in a former JB Hi-Fi shop that is on several levels. It claims to be wheel-chair friendly, but it’s not.  There’s an unusually high step to enter the shop, with very  narrow ramp that can be used to get to the door if you can’t negotiate the step.  But it’s not a proper ramp and once you enter, there are then about three further steps without a hand-rail to negotiate.  There is a voting booth on the entry level, but someone has to alert the staff at the back that a voter needs to access it.  I don’t know how some people would have been able to enter had it not been for the party volunteers outside who took off their badges and left their leaflets with someone from the opposing parties to distribute (which they did) in order to help someone up the stairs and tell the staff that someone needed to use the street-level booth.  It shouldn’t require this much assistance in something that is supposed to be accessible.

Then there’s the voting paper itself.  Do we really need 97 candidates in the Senate?  You can choose to vote ‘1’ in the Senate and the pre-arranged preferences will flow from that- but who do these preferences go to?  The presence in the Senate of ultra-conservative Family First candidates who were voted in through the re-distributed preferences from progressive parties is a cautionary tale.  I checked the website of the Greens but there is no information there, and when I emailed them to ask they referred me to the AEC site.

http://www.aec.gov.au/election/vic/gvt.htm

It took some finding, but it’s there.  Ye Gods.  Second preferences for the Greens? The Wikileaks party. Great. Not.  And is there a nice little print-friendly version that you can download to take with you if you’re going to grit your teeth and fill in the 97 boxes?  Nup- just the one version that has all the voting preferences of every grouping (all 4366 permutations) with  Danny Nalliah of the Rise-Up Party as the number one candidate because he lucked out in the candidate draw. (No doubt the result of prayer.)

Then there’s the ticket viewer at  Below the Line at http://www.belowtheline.org.au/viewer/vic  

It has a rather natty little tool where you can compare the tickets of two groupings by selecting the grouping you want from the pull down box and all the names will miraculously re-arrange.  You can see two different voting patterns side-by-side if you select two different groupings. But there’s no facility for a print-out showing the preferences in the order that they will be shown on the voting paper to take with you on this site either.

So, you have a choice of numbering just ‘1’ or filling in 97 boxes. How about something in between- 10 perhaps?  At what point does too much choice become undemocratic?

Humpf. I told you I was grumpy.

 

Advertisements

6 responses to “Too much ‘democracy’?

  1. Congratulations – today’s posting is a ripper 🙂
    I’ll be very interested to see how high the informal vote is this time around.
    This goes a long way towards explaining why I can’t help feeling we’re now being disenfranchised by stealth.

    • Thank you for commenting. I think that it will be a very very high informal vote. Part of me feels like doing the same, except that I respect the process too much and know how hard-won a well-run electoral system is. I was appalled to read, too, that one in four ‘young’ voters are not enrolled.

  2. I pretty much agree with your sentiments. I am of a certain age, as are you, and I can never remember such disaffection with the leading candidates as at this election. We should be so happy to be exercising our our democratic right and duty in a reasonably fair electoral process without getting beaten up because we didn’t vote for a despot. Instead of enjoying the privilege we feel very negative about it.

    • I am often struck by the sheer bravery of people being marked with INDELIBLE ink after voting in some countries, when there are so many ill-intentioned people who would want to stop them doing so.

  3. Great grumpy post Janine.

  4. I really hope that there is some reform of the Senate voting process after the election. The current situation is ridiculous. Here is Antony Green’s advice on how to approach filling in the Senate voting paper and his thoughts on this mess.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s